Ae Dil Hai Mushkil vs Shivaay box office collection Day 9: Rs 84.75cr ranbir ADHM, Rs 75.02cr SHIVAAY

While ranbir's Ae Dil Hai Mushkil has earned Rs 84.75 crore in India in seven days, Ajay Devgn's Shivaay has earned Rs 75.02 crore.

While Ae Dil Hai Mushkil has earned Rs 84.75 crore in India in seven days, Shivaay has earned Rs 75.02 crore.

Here is the detailed break-up of the box office collection of Ae Dil Hai Mushkil and Shivaay after their first week at the box office:

AE DIL HAI MUSHKIL:
Day 1 - Friday (October 28): Rs 13.3 crore
Day 2 - Saturday (October 29): Rs 13.1 crore
Day 3 - Sunday (October 30): Rs 9.2 crore
Day 4 - Monday (October 31): Rs 17.75 crore
Day 5 - Tuesday (November 1): Rs 13.03 crore
Day 6 - Wednesday (November 2): Rs 7.63 crore
Day 7 - Thursday (November 3): Rs 6.18 crore
Day 8 - Friday (November 4): Rs 4.56 crore
Total collection (8 days): Rs 84.75 crore

SHIVAAY:
Day 1 - Friday (October 28): Rs 10.24 crore
Day 2 - Saturday (October 29): Rs 10.06 crore
Day 3 - Sunday (October 30): Rs 8.26 crore
Day 4 - Monday (October 31): Rs 17.35 crore
Day 5 - Tuesday (November 1): Rs 11.05 crore
Day 6 - Wednesday (November 2): Rs 7.4 crore
Day 7 - Thursday (November 3): Rs 6.05 crore
Day 8 - Friday (November 4): Rs 4.61 crore
Total collection (8 days): Rs 75.02 crore
Both Ae Dil Hai Mushkil and Shivaay have received mixed reviews, mostly tilting towards the negative. On the one hand, Ae Dil Hai Mushkil has been criticised for slotting Ranbir Kapoor in the same old man-child role he has done earlier in Rockstar, Tamasha, Barfi! and Wake Up Sid. Other criticisms include implausible storylines, manipulative plot developments and excessive glossiness.

Meanwhile, Shivaay has been lauded for its state-of-the-art special effects but the film (directed by and starring Ajay Devgn) has received flak for simplistic, melodramatic storytelling and laughable villains.